Following the Bulls’ clutch 16-13 victory over Munster at Thomond Park, listed below are our 5 takeaways from the United Rugby Championship conflict.
High line
A real arm-wrestle because the Bulls created historical past, changing into the primary South African crew to knock over Munster at Thomond Park within the United Rugby Championship.
Jake White’s costs emerged victorious courtesy of a contentious Marcell Coetzee strive in addition to two Johan Goosen penalties and a clutch kick from Keagan Johannes.
Jack Crowley transformed all three of his pictures on aim, together with the conversion of Thaakir Abrahams’ strive, however that was not sufficient to see his crew over the road after the plethora of setbacks within the build-up to and in the course of the match.
Munster lineout woes proceed
One other week, one other poor lineout show from the Munster pack. There was a notable enchancment from the diabolical exhibiting towards Bordeaux final week, however frankly, it might solely enhance from that embarrassment.
As soon as once more, it value the Irish province perfect attacking positions. Munster appears to be like set to make the play-offs from this level, but when they’re to go deep into the competitors but once more, they should discover some consistency on the set-piece. If not, then their play-off run will likely be short-lived.
It’s not only a truth of failing to safe possession from the lineout however the high quality of the ball they obtain from it. So typically, they resorted to going to the entrance jumper, the banker ball, however that requires the scrum-half to throw a 15-metre move not less than to get the backline firing and the defence has that point to shoot up. This made it tough for Alex Nankivell, Tom Farrell and others to recover from the benefit line and gave Crowley much less time and house to decide.
This clearly has a knock-on impact on the remainder of the assault. With the lineout remaining one of many richest sources of tries, notably in these sorts of circumstances, Ian Costello must discover a repair and quick.
Bulls Boks present path
After a woeful begin to their Problem Cup knockout match final week, White opted to start out his Springboks stars towards Munster this time round and was rewarded by doing so.
The likes of Goosen, Canan Moodie, Embrose Papier, and Jan-Hendrik Wessels had been elevated to the beginning line-up and all carried out nicely in difficult circumstances.
Goosen, particularly, was wonderful as he steered the assault nicely and performed in the suitable areas of the park. The Bulls have struggled in his absence in latest weeks and at the moment he confirmed the standard he brings at quantity 10 after White was pressured to make use of makeshift choices within the type of Willie le Roux and Johannes. Whereas the latter got here on and performed an enormous function within the victory, he had a powerful platform to work with due to the work accomplished by Goosen.
Final week, White additionally changed Coetzee at half-time after the skilled back-rower had produced a person of the match efficiency the week prior and this time round he was rewarded once more for leaving him on for your entire 80 minutes.
Stormers v Connacht: 5 takeaways as Springboks sensation’s efforts overshadowed by ‘shambolic’ defence in controversial end
Stormers participant rankings: ‘Freakish’ Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu scores a marvellous hat-trick as Evan Roos presses for Springboks recall
14 males for 14 minutes
A troublesome evaluate awaits Andrea Piardi after at the moment’s exhibiting with the Italian official admitting that there are “too many guidelines on this recreation” after his blunder resulted in Munster enjoying with 14 males for 14 minutes.
This occurred when substitute tighthead prop Stephen Archer was pressured off the pitch and we had been subjected to uncontested scrums because the Munster veteran had come on for Oli Jager, who had failed his HIA within the first half.
The place the referee went flawed was that he believed that the Irish province ought to have gone down a person which isn’t the case. Within the occasion of a head damage to 1 front-row and a “contact damage” to a different, and there aren’t any different suitably skilled replacements to fill the place, the referee should name for uncontested scrums and NOT lose a person with one other substitute merely approaching.
Munster right down to 14 and until I’m mistaken, looks as if the inaccurate name from the officers pic.twitter.com/5ZbEnQNsd4
— CaolánSRugby (@CaolanSRugby) April 19, 2025
Nonetheless, Piardi ordered Munster to go down a participant with Alex Kendellen leaving the pitch. This sparked discussions on the sidelines and ultimately Munster’s case was heard and confirmed proper, with Kendellen returning, albeit 14 minutes later.
That was a transparent error on the referee’s half and one which understandably aggravated captain Tadhg Beirne. Nonetheless, it was not the one name that may have angered the Munster followers with Coetzee’s strive additionally coming from an error.
Piardi and his officiating crew failed to note that Bulls quantity eight Cameron Hanekom had taken the fast faucet resulting in the strive by bouncing the ball off his thigh.
World Rugby regulation 20.8 on the subject of taking a penalty or free-kick, states: “The kicker might punt, drop-kick or place-kick (apart from for contact) the ball.”
A faucet and go, as it’s usually referred to, is basically a punt and in World Rugby clarification all the best way again in 2004, it states that “A kick is made by hitting the ball with any a part of the leg or foot, besides the heel, from the toe to the knee however not together with the knee.”
In line with that clarification, Hanekom’s actions ought to have been deemed a “knock-on or throw ahead” which means that Munster would have gotten the scrum. As an alternative, the Bulls scored a number of phases later.
Nigel Owens: Why referee press conferences received’t work regardless of the necessity for ‘openness and transparency’
Munster combat
Though Munster received’t be pleased with the consequence, they’ll actually be pleased with the hassle regardless of the a number of setbacks they suffered.
Craig Casey and Peter O’Mahony had been each named within the beginning line-up however withdrew earlier than kick-off, with Conor Murray and Jack O’Donoghue filling the void whereas Paddy Patterson and Rory Scannell had been added to the bench.
They had been additional disrupted when Jager was pressured off the pitch within the opening quarter-hour, and regardless of requires Coetzee’s attempt to unnecessarily happening to 14 males, they confirmed actual coronary heart and willpower to remain inside touching distance of a win.
Whereas the lineout stays an space of actual concern, the coaches will likely be happy that, like many Munster squads earlier than this one, there isn’t a lack of effort or coronary heart when pulling on that jersey.
It was simply as a lot of a personality win for White’s costs, who few would have fancied to get a consequence at Thomond Park however the Pretoria-based franchise rose to the problem. Even after they confronted adversity of their very own as considered one of their largest weapons, the scrum, was taken away from them. The Bulls additionally conceded a a lot greater penalty depend, 9-14, and have been on the highway for a 3rd successive week.
READ MORE: The novel TMO change Steve Diamond has referred to as for following his six-match ban
